Report Numbness feet in Injuries Posted May 16, 2015 I had the same problem, first the numbness then pain. I went to see podiatrist and found out I had Morton's nerouma (pinched nerve) in both feet! You should get your feet measurements length and especially width! I have size 7 double E and most shoes are made in a B width and constantly squeezing my feet in shoes that weren't wide enough caused the problem. Hope this helps some!